Sell Magic Singles

Just Games is east side Rochester‘s source for Magic: the Gathering singles. We have a wide selection of Standard singles, but we also stock over a half-million individual cards in our card catalog, ranging from ultra-rare Legacy and Vintage staples like Moxes and Dual Lands, to casual EDH cards like Thrumming Stone and Gamble. We open thousands of packs so that you don’t have to!

Trading in and selling Magic Cards

We buy new, unplayed, Magic singles. Open a card at a draft and want to return it for store credit? We can do that! The rates below should give you a general idea of what to expect, but please note that in stock quantity may have a positive or negative impact on these prices.

General MTG Trade Rates

Trade in Store Credit Toward MTG Singles = 70% of your card’s value

Trade in for Store Credit = 50-60% of your card’s value

Cash = Varies, but typically 20-50% of your card’s value. Cards under $5 are generally purchased for a lesser percentage than cards over $5.

When selling quantities greater than 20 cards at a time, please call ahead to schedule an appointment.

Bulk Rates

Bulk commons & uncommons, unsorted, facing same direction = $3 / 1000

Bulk Basic land, unsorted, facing same direction = $5 / 1000

Bulk Rares, unsorted = $.10 per card

Bulk foils, unsorted = $.05 per card

Bulk Pokemon Cards = $5 / 1000

For bulk quantities greater than 20,000 please call ahead to schedule an appointment.

We reserve the right to refuse any trade, at any time, for any reason. To trade in cards you must be 18 or older, possess a valid government issued ID, own all cards traded in, and provide Just Games with a phone number, signature and address at which you may be contacted if necessary. We reserve the right to refuse any card valued at $15 or more for any reason.


How do you value cards?

We use a combination of TCGPlayer’s Professional software and a proprietary database that collects the prices that individual cards have actually¬†sold for in the last 72 hours across multiple online markets (Ebay, Amazon, TCG, etc). This ensures that buy and sell prices are as accurate as possible. This methodology removes 99.9% of errors from card pricing, and ensures both parties are getting up to the minute market information.